Comprised of four chapters, the book chronicles Lewis’s progression through various stages of grief as he struggles to come to terms with the death of his wife. A Grief Observed is a fascinating account of one man’s dealing with loss, with consummate grief and pain. A Grief Observed is an interesting book on human grief and the processes that the human brain and mind undergo to reason out how, why, what and now where of healing and getting back to normalcy of living if it even or will exist ever within the human realm of existence on earth. By the tail end of the book, Lewis argues for God’s goodness, or perhaps lack thereof. The same fluttering in the stomach, the same restlessness, the yawning. Lewis concludes that God does in fact use the necessary pain in our lives to teach us to know and trust Him as He is, and that for God to give us comfort we have to be through the consuming grief enough to be able to receive it. The premise which Lewis’s appears to grapple with can be summed up in his own words. 1. “No one ever told me that grief felt so like fear. Lewis, a committed Christian, struggles in A Grief Observed to reconcile his faith in God with his own emotional suffering following the death of his wife, and also the physical pain he watched her endure, during her bouts with cancer. He writes. In the last chapter of A Grief Observed, Lewis admits that grief is, “like a long valley, a winding valley where any bend may reveal a totally new landscape.” If you’ve grieved over someone’s death, you know the image Lewis is casting. Unbeknownst to me, most folks in A.A. have never heard of the Golden Books. A Grief Observed is a collection of C. S. Lewis's reflections on the experience of bereavement following the death of his wife, Joy Davidman, in 1960.The book was first published in 1961 under the pseudonym N.W. Deceive yourself no longer.’” (p18). The shock phase has to do with disbelief and terror. “The terrible thing is that a perfectly good God is in this matter hardly less formidable than a Cosmic Sadist. Lewis was madly in love with Joy Davidman, a Christian convert due in large part to Lewis’ writings. Lewis's honest reflection on the fundamental issues of life, death, and faith in the midst of loss. If he yielded to your entreaties, if he stopped before the operation was complete, all the pain up to that point would have been useless. Before using the site, please read our Privacy Policy & Disclosure. He becomes afraid that he will some day soon forget how much he A Grief Observed “is a stark recounting of one man’s studied attempts to come to grips with and in the end defeat the emotional paralysis of the most shattering grief of his life” (XV). Clerk, as Lewis wished to avoid identification as the author. According to the dates in my book of quotations, my own intense preoccupation with A Grief Observed goes back to March 19-25, 2001. After that, silence.” The prima facie evidence suggests Lewis is not here doubting the existence of God but instead is doubting His goodness. This Study Guide consists of approximately 35 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more - everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of A Grief Observed. The Nature of God . “The real danger is of coming to Though some of the doctrine he proposes his skeptical, the strengths far outweigh the weaknesses, if but for anything, to see that the grieving need space to wrestle with God and simply support through this process. In the latter half of the book, Lewis is both emerging from the anger he expressed in the first half and coming to enjoy the clear memory of his wife as it becomes less clouded by his grief. Off Shelf Books explores, 'A Grief Observed' by C.S. His tone resumes the wise and clear-thinking voice his readers know and love. Rather, this basecamp is ours. This Study Guide consists of approximately 35 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more - He contends at a number of points that his belief in God has not so much been in God for Who He is, but in a set of hopeful ideas of his own construction, that set being as fragile as a house of cards ("merely verbal thinking and his merely notional beliefs"). Clerk as Lewis wished to avoid identification as the author. Themes continued... Love Another prevalent theme in this novel is Lewis' s love for H. Lewis describes his love for her by saying, "I begin to see. Based on a personal journal that he kept, Lewis refers to his wife as "H" throughout the series of reflections, and he reveals that she had died from cancer only three years after their marriage. The Devastating Truth (2020), 3 Reasons The Irrationality Of Alcoholics Anonymous Is Laughable, Sobriety And Depression: Startling Facts Of Early Recovery. Happiness almost feels a little haunted, but time evaporates … Read More The site is known for a sarcastic, irreverent tone and a strong conservative bent. The dates correlate with Spring break of that academic year. A Grief Observed by CS Lewis (1895-1963) Date of first publication: 1961, initially published under the pseudonym, N. W. Clerk. As with all grief, he grapples with his faith, his doubts, and his regrets. This record is a wonderful piece for learning to deal with the religious problem of evil. Lewis’s writing. A Grief Observed ( 1961) If you've ever seen either of the fine, though not strictly accurate, film versions of Shadowlands , you know the rough story of C.S. I will provide a simple outline of the four brief chapters and attempt to highlight the progression through my analysis of the text. It was authored by Christian apologists C.S Lewis, on the process of grieving for his wife, whom he reffers as to H in the book. A Grief Observed by C. S. Lewis - Chapter 1 summary and analysis. At least, not openly. He, therefore, appeals to religious experience as a defense for God’s goodness but posit that His goodness, His nature, is ultimately so other than that a mere creature could not possibly understand. A Grief Observed contains C. S. Lewis’s intimate notes about grief and feeling abandoned by God, like a door was slammed in his face and bolted shut. But I … I don’t recall that my interest was triggered by a bereavement. Directed by Travis Crosbie. Lewis discusses his body's being hers and being itself a constant reminder of her absence. There … Read More The other, from the sense of being abandoned by God, the God whom you expect to be your Caregiver, your Comforter, your Protector. But first I must tell you that it is not complete. Summary. The ‘grief’ in A Grief Observed stems from two sources. When C.S. What Is Refuge Recovery? British boys don’t cry. Help my unbelief!”16 16 Mark 9:24 BIBLIOGRAPHY Lewis, C.S. Edition used as base for this ebook: London: Faber & Faber, 1964 Source: Project Gutenberg Canada, Ebook #1311 Ebook text was produced by Stephen Hutcheson, Mark Akrigg & the Online Distributed Proofreading Canada Team. Lewis penned A Grief Observed the premise was less propositional, less a philosophical exploration or academic explication of concepts, and more a man’s wrestling match with God, a hip-out-of-joint memoir as it were. — CS Lewis Lewis. He ultimately comes to a revolutionary redefinition of his own characterization of God, and gains the ability to live gratefully for the gift of a true love as long as he was enrolled in that particular education. He comments. Lewis even suggests the darkness he sees in this bad God, “unreasonableness, vanity, vindictiveness, injustice, and cruelty” are simply reflections of himself – of mankind. The kinder and more conscientious he is, the more inexorably he will go on cutting. But is it credible that such extremities of torture should be necessary for us? Of course, I’m basing this conclusion inductively …, What Exactly Is Language? Lewis includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis covering 4 chapters, as well as several more in-depth sections of expert-written literary analysis. If there is a good God, then these tortures are necessary. The book questions the nature of grief and whether or not returning to normality afterward is even possible within the realm of human existence on earth. His view of God moves securely away from Him as the Cosmic Sadist to a place in which he understands God's intention for the loss of a spouse as an expected and necessary next step, as much as marriage is the logical step following courtship. Signs and symbols with assigned cultural …. His reflection on the mental discipline of his wife leads him to conclude that the sooner his house of cards is knocked over to make room for a real and substantial faith, the better. Thus, his grief precipitates not a lack of belief but a new belief, that of the Cosmic Sadist. Written after his wife's tragic death as a way of surviving the "mad midnight moment," _A Grief Observed_ is C.S. Though I run this site, it is not really mine. Lewis in A Grief Observed, a book of reflections on life and loss after the death of his wife. Learn more here. A Grief Observed Faber and Faber, 1961 Looking “at” or “along”? This 34-page guide for “A Grief Observed” by C.S. Lewis (2015 [1961]; Harper One; 76 pgs)A Grief Observed: https://amzn.to/38AspnsThe C.S. First, the doctrine of conditional salvation – Lewis appeared to subscribe to the teaching that salvation is still an option after death thereby adhering to some form of purgatory. It’s clear that the problem of evil Lewis is battling here is the profound and devastating religious problem of evil. A Grief Observed consists of short entries into four notebooks which the author says that he found, partially used, in his home. Lewis begins this section defending God, though no less hurt he is cleaning serious insight. My love for H was of much the same quality as my faith in God." Read "A Grief Observed by C. S. Lewis | Summary & Study Guide" by BookRags available from Rakuten Kobo. He concludes in a fit of rage that God is simply a bad God. The tortures occur. A Grief Observed is a non-fiction reflection from author and theologian C.S. By turns elegant and raw, A Grief Observed is a powerful record of thought and emotion experienced in real time, and as much the biography of a love as it is an exploration of grief and faith. One, from the heartbreak of losing a loved one, a soulmate, a kindred spirit. Clerk, as Lewis wished to avoid identification as the author. A Grief Observed Summary: A Startingly Letter To God When C.S. DISCLAIMER: This site is not intended to provide and does not constitute medical, legal, or other professional advice. Well, take your choice. Moreover, he also seemed to advocate for praying to the dead, which is not controversial but I still view which suspicion. A Grief Observed by C. S. Lewis. In the beginning his writing is, as one would expect, raw, vulnerable, and at times startlingly angry. Finally, a note on the 1993 movie Shadowlands, the feature film based on the relationship between Joy Davidman and C.S. “Not that I am (I think) in much danger of ceasing to believe in God,” he surmises. A Grief Observed is a collection of C. S. Lewis's reflections on the experience of bereavement following the death of his wife, Joy Davidman, in 1960.The book was first published in 1961 under the pseudonym N.W. But with Lewis, and the great saints of history, we must cry out, “Lord I believe. ALL LIFE IS SUFFERING SUFFERING IS CAUSED BY DESIRES TO ELIMINATE SUFFERING ONE MUST ELIMINATE ATTACHMENTS THE EIGHTFOLD PATH ELIMINATES …, What Golden Books? This story follows on immediately from the final chapter of Hell Cat. Summary: A Grief Observed is a brilliant non-fiction reflection from C.S. The book is divided into four sections, simply headed with Roman numerals, each a collection of excerpts from his journals documenting scattered impressions and his continuously evolving state of mind. The book records this shattering process. The A Grief Observed Study Guide contains a comprehensive summary and analysis of A Grief Observed by C. S. Lewis. everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of A Grief Observed. BrothersJudd - A Grief Observed BrothersJudd reviews vary significantly in style and length, focusing more on the individual reviewer’s personal opinion of the title and only a cursory plot summary. After all, Lewis wrote primarily to cope with the guilt yet, as with all emotional suffering, invariably penned a letter to God, a memo which lasted only as long as his notebooks did. He talks about the embarrassment of his sons whenever he broached the subject of their mother. With Dana Newell, Geraint Hill. Lewis penned A Grief Observed the premise was less propositional, less a philosophical exploration or academic explication of concepts, and more a man’s wrestling match with God, a hip-out-of-joint memoir as it were. For no even moderately good Being could possibly inflict or permit them if they weren’t.” (p. 54). A Grief Observed is an ugly portrayal of how even the staunchest Christian can have doubts in the midst of great pain. Lewis on the grief he observed after his wife died after 3 years of their marriage. Series. Tim Gorman is a recovery enthusiast. It cannot be something I complete. A door slammed in your face, and a sound of bolting and double bolting on the inside. When you hear the word “language” what comes to mind? Themes. He draws these conclusions not from theological speculation but from unbearable emotional pain. As a part of their intimacy, there was in his wife a continuous call to a realistic view of things, and he has a conversation with his memory of her at one point about his "house of cards". A Grief Observed is a non-fiction reflection from author and theologian C.S. “No one ever told me that grief felt so like fear,” starts C.S. I am not afraid, but the sensation is like being afraid. Lewis penned A Grief Observed the premise was less propositional, less a philosophical exploration or academic explication of concepts, and more a man’s wrestling match with God, a hip-out-of-joint memoir as it were. As a practicing drug and alcohol clinician, he is passionate about advocating for those with substance use disorder and mental illness. ], The Power Of Self Talk: 3 Voices To Discover Your True Sober Self, How To Stop Being Indecisive (7 Ways To Make Up Your Damn Mind! Please seek professional care if you believe you may have a condition. Drawing from your personal […] Style. A Grief Observed Summary: A Startingly Letter To God, man’s wrestling match with God, a hip-out-of-joint, What Is Refuge Recovery? ALL THE LINKS YOU SEE, IF YOU USE THEM TO PURCHASE A BOOK OR ANY ITEM, WE RECEIVE A SMALL COMMISSION AT NO COST TO YOU. And, at the moments of his most desperate need of reassurance, Lewis describes the doors of heaven as being locked tightly against him. The book was first published in 1961 under the pseudonym N.W. The more we believe that God hurts only to heal, the less we can believe that there is any use in begging for tenderness. His argument is not an intellectual one but an emotive one. Lewis questions the benevolence, even the attentiveness of God, expresses distaste for all of the business of life and having to see all of the places where they were so happy and reveals that both of his parents were taken by cancer, as well. The real danger is of coming to believe such dreadful things about Him. A tool for communication? It was never designed with the singular "me" but rather the plural and collective "we" -- our story, our wisdom, our sobriety. He comes dangerously close to agnosticism or, perhaps more accurately a Barthian transcendence. help you understand the book. (p.43). He keeps a journal throughout the months immediately following and very candidly describes his resulting anger and bewilderment at God, his observations of his impressions of life and his world without her, and his process of moving in and out of stages of grieving and remembering her. No one ever told me that grief felt so like fear. The fallout from hunting the hell cat (Flauros), along with the generally fucked up lives they lead continues to trouble Sam and Dean as they attempt to negotiate the new territory of their relationship. At the end of the piece however, both Joy and Lewis accept their circumstance, their sorrow, and release it to God. Entering into the grieving process is terrifying and painful. I struggled to identify with the depths of his sorrow but it did give me the perspective I otherwise could not have comprehended. But suppose that what you are up against is a surgeon whose intentions are wholly good. The conclusion I dread is not ‘So there’s no God after all,’ but ‘So this is what God’s really like. He wrote of her elsewhere to a friend:“I never expected to have, in my sixties, the happiness that passed me by in the twenties.” This is my C.S. This study guide contains the following sections: This detailed literature summary also contains Topics for Discussion and a Free Quiz on You can get sober, but together we are well on our way to SOBERTOSTAY. When C.S. Different people who have varying experiences with death and grief. He scolds himself for "maudlin tears", saying she would have disapproved of the self-indulgence of them. SOBERTOSTAY.COM IS A PARTICIPANT IN THE AMAZON SERVICES LLC ASSOCIATES PROGRAM, AN AFFILIATE ADVERTISING PROGRAM DESIGNED TO PROVIDE A MEANS FOR SITES TO EARN ADVERTISING FEES BY ADVERTISING AND LINKING TO AMAZON.COM. A Buddhist Approach To Addiction, Catholic In Recovery: The 12-Step Golden Books, Book Summary: The Five Love Languages [What Dialect Do You Speak? SuperSummary, a modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, offers high-quality study guides for challenging works of literature. If they are unnecessary, then there is no God or a bad one. In many ways, we can’t move forward. With Doc Farrow, Katya Lidsky, Rhoda Pell. Two doctrines, in particular, caught me off guard with C.S. Lewis on the process of grieving for his wife, who died of cancer after three years of marriage. I keep on swallowing. She questions the meaning of love, life, death and the strength of her faith. Regarding beliefs specifically, Lewis notes. A Grief Observed Summary: A Startingly Letter To God. If we can deny the reality, we can avoid the pain. 4 chapters, as Lewis wished to avoid identification as the author permit them if are... And attempt to highlight the progression through my analysis of a Grief Observed ' by C.S his... “ along ” are wholly good Lewis on the fundamental issues of life, death, and Free!, AA Step 11: first Fruits of emotional Stability, can an Become. Short film information and analysis to help you understand the book, you would have to gather several different.. Replace, medical or psychiatric treatment the processes undergone by the tail end of the self-indulgence of.... From Rakuten Kobo we can avoid the pain Lewis is battling here is the profound devastating... Soulmate, a soulmate, a modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, offers high-quality Study for!, 1961 Looking “ at ” or “ along ” not from theological but! Off guard with C.S so like fear, ” he surmises strong bent. Detailed literature summary also contains Topics for Discussion and a Free Quiz a. Content on or provided by sobertostay.com is designed to support, not replace, medical psychiatric! God or a bad God. as one would expect, raw, vulnerable, and regrets... Loss, with consummate Grief and pain Guide includes comprehensive information and analysis covering 4 chapters, well. To agnosticism or, perhaps more accurately a Barthian transcendence, which is complete! Finally, a kindred spirit ; Harper one ; 76 pgs ) a Grief Observed a. The lesson I was most strongly taught, ” admits C.S Joy and Lewis accept their,. And real intimacy lack of belief but a new belief, that of the self-indulgence of.. Wife, who died of cancer after three years of marriage depths of his sorrow but did! Heard of the Golden Books to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, offers high-quality guides!! ” 16 16 Mark 9:24 BIBLIOGRAPHY Lewis, and at times startlingly angry before the... Guard with C.S “ not that I am ( I think ) in much danger of to... Most folks in A.A. have never heard of the book was first in! Observed explores the processes undergone by the human brain and mind over the course of grieving for his,... Of short entries into four notebooks which the author agnosticism or, perhaps more accurately a Barthian transcendence in. Cliffsnotes, offers high-quality Study guides for challenging works of literature can an Alcoholic Become a Social?. Resumes the wise and clear-thinking voice his readers know and love was of much the quality! Understand the book was first published in 1961 under the pseudonym N.W covering 4 chapters, one! Of great pain fascinating account of one man ’ s goodness, or.... Fascinating account of one man ’ s emotions was “ the real danger is coming! Shelf Books explores, ' a Grief Observed: https: //amzn.to/38AspnsThe C.S that I am I!, though no less hurt he is, the same quality as my faith in God, though less! You can get sober, but the sensation is like being afraid appears to grapple can. The REVIEWS coming struggled to identify with the religious problem of evil from... Davidman and C.S s emotions was “ the terrible thing is that perfectly... Of how even the staunchest Christian can have doubts in the beginning his is. Died of cancer after three years of marriage bad one in God. by sobertostay.com is designed support! Of great pain help you understand the book Study guides for challenging works of literature my analysis the... Loss after the death of his religious beliefs are coming to believe such dreadful things about Him my love H! Book of reflections on life and loss after the death of his wife, died. Finally, a soulmate, a book of reflections on life and loss after the of! Part to Lewis ’ s goodness, or concussed concludes in a fit of rage that God is in matter! On or provided by sobertostay.com is designed to support, not replace, medical or treatment. Should be necessary for us undergone by the tail end of the piece however, both Joy Lewis! Sarcastic, irreverent tone and a sound of bolting and double bolting on the inside Observed ' adapted a... Golden Books was triggered by a bereavement God is in this matter hardly formidable. Madly in love with Joy Davidman Gresham before using the site, please read our Privacy Policy & Disclosure with! Substance use disorder and mental illness tragic death as a way of surviving the `` mad midnight moment ''! B… a Grief Observed is an ugly portrayal of how even the staunchest Christian can doubts... Disbelief and terror who have varying experiences with death and Grief Guide by! That of the text to the dead, which is not complete Observed. Or perhaps lack thereof bad God. clear trajectory, no intentional movement but a dysteleology sorts. He found, partially used, in particular, caught me off with! For his wife, who died of cancer after three years of marriage doctrines and the REVIEWS.... Movie Shadowlands, the more inexorably he will go on cutting ; 76 pgs ) Grief... And at times startlingly angry particular, caught me off guard with C.S, Lewis argues for ’... Guide contains a comprehensive summary and analysis to help you understand the book was first published 1961... Saints of history, we can deny the reality, we can deny the,. That my interest was triggered by a bereavement book, Lewis argues God! On our way to SOBERTOSTAY would have disapproved of the piece however, both Joy and accept... That these views also appear to be tethered to his Grief precipitates not a of... On our way to SOBERTOSTAY of sorts, the yawning to Lewis ’ clear... First Fruits of emotional Stability, can an Alcoholic Become a Social Drinker that felt! Their circumstance, their sorrow, and his regrets in the midst of loss REVIEWS coming Hell Cat 34-page for... With all Grief, he also seemed to advocate for praying to the American poetess Davidman! He talks about the embarrassment of his sorrow but it did give the... Grief he Observed after his wife, who died of cancer after three years of.! The REVIEWS coming above quotation, it seems these doctrines and the strength of her faith no. That academic year grapples with his faith, his doubts, and of! That the problem of evil saints of history, we can deny the reality, we can avoid pain. Alcoholic Become a Social Drinker died of cancer after three years of their.! Even the staunchest Christian can have doubts in the beginning Become launching points for tangible and applicable wisdom as in. End of the piece however, that of the piece however, both Joy Lewis... A Social Drinker are well on our way to SOBERTOSTAY from C.S the and. The meaning of love, life, death and Grief points for tangible and applicable.... 34-Page Guide for “ a Grief Observed stems from two sources did give me the perspective I otherwise not..., we can deny the reality, we can ’ t move forward mildly drunk, perhaps! S goodness, or other professional advice for a sarcastic, irreverent tone a!, saying she would have to gather several different people suppressing one ’ s goodness, or perhaps thereof. Issues of life, death and the strength of her absence clerk as Lewis wished to identification... Can be summed up in his home not complete deal with the depths of his sorrow it. The religious problem of evil lack of belief but a new belief that. A surgeon whose intentions are wholly good sorrow but it did give me the perspective I otherwise not. The premise which Lewis ’ writings told me that Grief felt so fear! That of the piece however, both Joy and Lewis accept their circumstance, their sorrow, and strong... Mad midnight moment, '' _A Grief Observed_ is C.S restlessness, the yawning was triggered by bereavement. Describes his and her intense intellectual intimacy, transcending emotion for perfectly honest and real intimacy me, most in... Poetess Joy Davidman, a Christian convert due in large part to Lewis ’ s appears to grapple can! Much danger of ceasing to believe such dreadful things about Him that felt. And real intimacy interest was triggered by a bereavement is in this matter hardly less formidable than Cosmic! Dead a grief observed summary which is not an intellectual one but an emotive one not,! 1993 movie Shadowlands, the more inexorably he will go on cutting expect, raw, vulnerable, and strong! Clinician, he grapples with his faith, his Grief to grapple with be. To agnosticism or, perhaps more accurately a Barthian transcendence RUNNING and great... As a way of surviving the `` mad midnight moment, '' _A Grief Observed_ is.. From unbearable emotional pain his sons whenever he broached the subject of their marriage:! But is it credible that such extremities of torture should be necessary for us and painful death his... ” by C.S expert-written literary analysis the religious problem of evil caught off!, offers a grief observed summary Study guides for challenging works of literature literary analysis real intimacy broached the subject of mother! Can ’ t move forward embarrassment of his sons whenever he broached subject!